Theirs, in our words
#37at 74%●●○○○h2 · h3 · 2× p · 12 words
Card five: Snap Liver Health & Detox from Snap Supplements, graded B-. The lowest grade on this page is still a B.
Why it works. Close the list. consensus
Why it sits here, and how it is written
Last place. With every rival graded B or better, the list reads as five good products, which makes the winner's lead look small.
A flat grade range takes the drama out of a ranking. The sibling page runs from the top grade down to a C-, which reads as a verdict.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. CS-P1's scores range widely by axis (from 3.0 to 10), so differences are visible. Keep ours.
See these lines on their page ↗#38at 76%●○○○○h2 · 3× p · 24 words
Three items under the pros heading: advertised third-party testing with a 90-day guarantee, a two-capsule serving compared with one softgel (a drawback filed as a pro), and broad positioning across detox, digestion and antioxidant support.
Why it works. Concede testing and guarantee. candor
Why it sits here, and how it is written
Pros slot of the last card. The template's count of three was filled, one of them with a con.
The heading is in capitals here and not on the other cards. The misfiled item shows the card was assembled without a read-through.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. Already in CS-P1. A misfiled line is a reminder to read every card in the built page, not in the config.
See these lines on their page ↗#39at 78%●●○○○h2 · 3× p · 33 words
Three cons that fit the product: its single-bottle price is above the winner's, its green tea can disagree with some users or medicines, and its benefits are spread over several botanicals.
Why it works. Mark it down on price and focus. contrastloss-aversion
Why it sits here, and how it is written
The price con compares with the winner's price, which this page never states. The focus con repeats the winner's position: one active against a blend.
A price comparison with no prices. The caution about green tea is the one new fact.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. Price comparisons need the figures. CS-P1 works cost per day from each rival's own site. Already has.
See these lines on their page ↗#40at 80%●○○○○4× p · 69 words
Four more cons describe a different product: a 30-softgel bottle, a carotenoid from the sea instead of traceable microalgae, a cost that climbs when dosing up to 12 mg, and a plain softgel sold for eyes, heart, brain and immunity.
Why it works. None on this page: these lines were written for a low-dose astaxanthin rival on the store's astaxanthin ranking and were left behind when the card was reused.
Why it sits here, and how it is written
No reason. Leftover rows at the end of the last card, the part of a template least likely to be proofread.
A production error, and an instructive one: it shows the liver pages were cloned from the astaxanthin ranking. These four keep the label-and-reason style of the sibling page. A reader who gets this far sees a capsule blend criticised for being a softgel.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: left out. Nothing to take except the warning. Our builder clones a donor page too, and asserts that donor strings are gone. Every sibling page needs the same check on every card, the last one most of all.
See these lines on their page ↗#41at 83%●○○○○h3 · p · 31 words
The verdict describes the right product: four actives (dandelion, CoQ10, green tea, standardised milk thistle) taken as two capsules a day, a familiar blend whose testing and 90-day refund window are both advertised.
Why it works. Describe the rival neutrally. candor
Why it sits here, and how it is written
Verdict slot, written for this product, between two sets of leftover lines. It shows the card was partly rewritten: the middle was done and both ends were left.
Accurate and flat. Surrounded by lines about another product, it reads as the odd one out.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. Already in CS-P1: a neutral description before the catch.
See these lines on their page ↗#42at 85%●○○○○h3 · p · 55 words
The bottom line is about another brand entirely: it names Life Extension, praises a phospholipid absorption feature, calls 4 mg underdosed, and says a cheap bottle is no longer cheap once enough softgels are taken to make 12 mg.
Why it works. None on this page: a second leftover from the astaxanthin ranking.
Why it sits here, and how it is written
No reason. The last paragraph of the last card was never rewritten.
The best-written paragraph on the page, and it belongs to a card that is not here: spoken, specific, with a turn. It shows how the store marks down a low-dose astaxanthin rival: price it at the full dose.
Planned for ours, before we wrote: kept the move. As a line here it is an error. As a move it is ours: price a rival at the full 12 mg, not per bottle. The gate holds 12 mg against 4 to 6 mg products. CS-P1 does this on the Rovina card and in the cost-per-day axis. Already has. b7
See these lines on their page ↗Ours, word for word
#5 · rival card
5 Rank
Astaxanthin Capsules (bottle)
Dr. Mercola Organic Astaxanthin 12 mg
A doctor’s catalogue brand with an organic claim on the label. The full 12 mg in one capsule, at a price that adds up over a year.
12 mg in one softgel
9.5 / 10
Third-party lab tested
3.0 / 10
Cost per day
6.0 / 10
Mercola ticks the first box cleanly: one capsule with a meal is the full 12 mg, and the label says organic. If you already order from the catalogue, it is an easy add.
The price is the story. Thirty capsules cost more than a month of any other product here except Rovina, and the 90-count does not close the gap by much. We found no third-party test or batch report on the product page, and no guarantee term stated beside the product.
✓ Pros
- One capsule a day is the full 12 mg
- An organic astaxanthin claim on the label
- Easy to add to an existing catalogue order
✗ Cons
- Among the highest costs per day on this list
- No third-party test or batch report on the product page
- No guarantee term stated beside the product
$$$ · one capsule a day Clean label, catalogue price
Proposed change 7 · Dr. Mercola card: who it suits waits on your verdict
Same move: the card ends on who should still buy it.
Last line of the card: “Who it suits: the buyer who already shops with Mercola.”