← lansilglobal · Copy-Chief
Rendered from products/lansilglobal/pricing/COPYCHIEF-calculator-r1.md

COPYCHIEF — Lansil Global pricing calculator, round 1 (2026-10-21)

Reviewed on the rendered copy of the four live screens (tools/brand-hub/copy/lansilglobal/calc-*.json, extracted 2026-10-20 at the default inputs: 1,000 orders a month, 1.4 items, 10 pallets). Angle: LG-A10 — rates on the page, the number before the call. Truth Gate as of 2026-10-20: o1 (30% under Alibaba), o3 (40% under the US average), f11–f23 confirmed; no testimonials or case studies supplied yet (the proof bank is its own program). Compliance is not this pass (CL-00).

Piece Classification

test, the slider and the dashboard on the bench. Each screen = hero → controls → the two columns → the lock (name, work email, phone unblurs the numbers) → the sources line → CTAs → footer. The lock, the fee labels, the sources line and the CTAs are shared code (calc/ui.js, calc/fees.json), so one fix lands on all four.

product-aware on Schwartz's scale: they know what a 3PL invoice looks like, they do not know one can have one line.

from dated survey averages. The other column never names a competitor (BRAND §6, 2026-10-14).

Big Picture Assessment

  1. Big idea / hook. Strong and different: rates on the page in a market that gates them, shown as the invoice they already resent.

The bill screen owns the idea — "Two bills for the same month" is bar-stool ready and sits in the competitor-attack bucket, not the mechanism bucket. The wizard ("Three questions. Then your number.") and the slider ("Move the slider. That's your rate.") promise speed and control; fine, but they are mechanism-bucket lines. The dashboard ("Your fulfillment cost, live.") is the weak one: abstract noun plus software-speak, in a market that distrusts "effortless" (m3). "Oh yeah, what does it do?" does not fire.

  1. The lead. No screen passes CL-06 fully: none of the four H1s carries the prospect's own problem-word. The invoice with fourteen

lines is the problem-word; only the bill screen's sub gets there ("Every line they add, we don't"). The wizard's step-2 line is the best lead sentence on any screen and it is buried on step 2.

  1. Reason why. The $0 column is the claim; the sources line is the reason-why for the OTHER column and it is good (dated, numbered,

"not any one company's rate card"). What is missing everywhere is the reason-why for OURS: why can Lansil bill one line? The Truth Gate has it (f4 privately owned, p1 one company across the chain). Thirteen zeros without a reason reads too good to be true.

  1. Offer stack. The number is the offer and the exchange is fair, but the lock sells it weakly: "tell us who to send them to" is a

small lie (nothing is sent, the blur comes off), and the small print promises a "follow up", the one thing a buyer fears. The guarantees confirmed yesterday (no hidden fees, no exit fees, no postage markups, free rework when QC fails, no minimums) are the strongest objection-killers a pricing page can carry and none of the four screens says them.

  1. Close / CTA. "Get a quote" + the phone number keeps the funnel's one vocabulary (CL-16), right. But after "You keep $1,507 a month"

there is no bridge: the quote restarts a sale the number already made. The bridge is the risk reversal: no minimums, no exit fees, the rate you see is the rate on the contract. Urgency is correctly absent (scarcity is banned, x6); the only honest "why now" is Q4, and the Q4 toggle already exists, the copy just never says what it does to the other column.

  1. Emotional throughline. Carried by the numbers, in a cool register that fits the market. No sag except the two fee labels that

end in "where reported", which read like a disclaimer inside the bill and leak doubt exactly where the gap is widest.

Cap on the score: no customer proof exists yet (Truth Gate x7 until the proof bank fills), so social proof cannot be added this round. The score is for what the rules allow today.

Line-Level Review

Shared lines (fix once in calc/ui.js / calc/fees.json, lands on all four screens)

S1 · the lock sub (all four). Location: «Your numbers are ready. Tell us who to send them to and the blur comes off. Keep moving the slider after that; we keep your latest numbers.» (wizard: «Your number is ready. Tell us who to send it to and the blur comes off.») Issue: "send them to" fails the believability test — nothing is sent, the blur lifts on the screen; the reader asks "send what, where?" at the exact moment they are deciding whether to type a phone number. Fix: «Your numbers are ready. Put a name on them and the blur comes off. Keep playing with the slider after that, we keep your latest numbers.» Wizard: «Your number is ready. Put a name on it and the blur comes off.» Principle: CL-22 believability; Halbert, enter the conversation already in their head.

S2 · the lock small print (all four). Location: «Your numbers stay on screen. A Lansil account manager follows up by text or email within one business day.» Issue: "follows up" is the sales call they dread, unnamed. Say what the contact is for. Fix: «Your numbers stay on screen. A Lansil account manager texts or emails within one business day to put this rate in writing.» Principle: specificity sells; name the outcome of the contact, not the contact.

S3 · the lock button on the dashboard. Location: «Save my numbers» Issue: the other three say what happens (Show me both bills · Show my number · Show my numbers); "save" is a different verb for the same act and promises less. Fix: «Show my numbers» Principle: CL-16, one vocabulary; the button names the thing you get.

S4 · the bridge above the CTAs (all four). Location: «Get a quote Call +1 702-462-2035» (no line above the buttons) Issue: after the gap the buttons restart the sale. The risk reversal the Truth Gate now allows is the bridge, and it is nowhere on the page. Fix: one line above the buttons, every screen: «The rate you see is the rate on the contract. No minimums, no exit fees, no postage markups.» Buttons unchanged. Principle: risk reversal at the close (f11, f16); CL-16 keeps the labels.

S5 · the reason-why line under the gap (all four). Location: the "You keep" line stands alone on every screen. Issue: thirteen zeros with no reason reads like a trick. The Truth Gate holds the reason (f4, p1). Fix: one line under the gap: «One company owns the chain, from the Shenzhen floor to the Nevada dock, so there is nobody in the middle to bill you for the second item.» Principle: every claim needs a reason why (Schwartz); CL-02 names the thing, never "the system".

S6 · fee label. Location: «Additional items — every item after the first (or after the free picks)» Issue: the parenthetical hedges the cleanest line in the bill. Fix: «Additional items — every item after the first» Principle: one idea per line.

S7 · two fee labels. Location: «Percentage add-ons — dashboard or payment-processing percentages, where reported» · «Peak-season surcharge — Q4 storage uplift, where reported» Issue: "where reported" is footnote language inside the invoice; the sources line already carries the hedge. Inside the bill it reads as doubt. Fix: «Percentage add-ons — dashboard or payment-processing percentages» · «Peak-season surcharge — the Q4 storage uplift» Principle: copy that sounds like a disclaimer leaks; keep the sourcing in the sources line.

Two bills (calc-bill) — 8/10

B1 · §01 hero sub. Location: «Yours at Lansil, and the one a typical US 3PL sends for the same orders. Every line they add, we don't. Change the numbers and watch both bills rewrite.» Issue: "Yours at Lansil" lands before the reader has seen either bill; the best sentence sits second. Fix: «Every line they add, we don't. The bill a typical US 3PL sends for your orders, next to ours. Change the numbers and watch both bills rewrite.» Principle: lead with the strongest line; CL-06 recognition first.

Everything else on this screen holds: the invoice framing («Invoice · one month · 1,000 orders», «One flat fee per order. Nothing else on the bill.»), «Industry survey averages, not any one company's rate card.», the toggles in plain words, the one-time onboarding row.

Three questions (calc-wizard) — 7.5/10

W1 · §01 H1 (optional test line, keep the control). Location: «Three questions. Then your number.» Issue: a speed promise, mechanism bucket; competent, not gripping. Fix (test): «Three questions. Then the number your 3PL hopes you never compare.» Principle: the hook test (a) — "oh yeah, what number?"; CL-22 bucket walk.

W2 · §04 the reveal. Location: «Your month at Lansil keeps you $1,507 a month. That is $18,079 a year and 38% less for the same 1,000 orders.» Issue: "keeps you $1,507" does not read in one breath, and the reveal is the emotional peak of this format. Fix: «At Lansil the same 1,000 orders leave $1,507 in your account every month. That is $18,079 a year, 38% less.» Principle: write like you talk; the peak must read aloud without a stumble.

W3 · §05 the lock sub. See S1 (wizard wording).

What works here: «The rivals bill every item after the first. We bill the order.» (the best lead sentence on any screen), the honest pallet guess («We've guessed from your orders; change it if you know it»), the four shipper options, «See every line of both bills», «Change my answers».

The slider (calc-slider) — 7.5/10

L1 · §01 hero sub (optional). Location: «One flat fee per order. No storage fee, no receiving fee, nothing for the second item in the box. Set your orders and compare the month with what a typical US 3PL bills for it.» Issue: none that costs a lead; "nothing for the second item in the box" is the most concrete line in the set. The count would sharpen it. Fix: «One flat fee per order. No storage fee, no receiving fee, nothing for the second item in the box: thirteen lines at $0. Set your orders and compare the month with what a typical US 3PL bills for it.» Principle: specificity.

What works: «Every line they bill. Every line we don't.» (the best H2 in the set, worth reusing as the ledger head on the dashboard), «It's Q4», the postage note (p5).

The dashboard (calc-dashboard) — 6/10

D1 · §01 H1. Location: «Your fulfillment cost, live.» Issue: abstract noun plus "live", a software word; no problem-word, no comparison; the hook test fails on both counts. Fix: «Every line a 3PL bills you, and the one line we do.» (or borrow the bill screen's «Two bills for the same month.») Principle: CL-06 recognition; CL-22 hook test (a).

D2 · §01 hero sub. Location: «…at Lansil and at the 3PL you'd compare us with. Change anything on the left and watch the gap move.» Issue: "the 3PL you'd compare us with" drifts from the vocabulary every other screen uses. Fix: «Per order, per day, per month, at Lansil and at a typical US 3PL. Change anything on the left and watch the gap move.» Principle: CL-18, one noun for the rival across the funnel.

D3 · §02 the "You keep" tile. Location: «$1,507 You keep, a month $18,079 a year, 38% less than typical US 3PL for the same 1,000 orders.» Issue: read in order the tile says "You keep, a month" and drops the article; scanned, it reads broken. Fix: label above the number «You keep each month», line below «$18,079 a year · 38% less than a typical US 3PL for the same 1,000 orders.» Principle: the scannable layer reads as sentences in any order.

D4 · §04 the bill lede. Location: «Every fee a 3PL adds, and what it reads at Lansil.» Issue: "what it reads at Lansil" is not how anyone says it. Fix: «Every fee a 3PL adds, and the same line at Lansil.» Principle: write like you talk.

D5 · §03 the lock button. See S3.

The Verdict

does not yet hold. The numbers do the selling and the register is right for this buyer; what is missing is the reason the zeros are real and the guarantees that make the call safe, both available since yesterday.

  1. S4 + S5 on every screen: the reason-why under the gap and the risk-reversal line above the CTAs (f4/p1, f11, f16).
  2. S1 + S2 (+ S3 on the dashboard): the lock stops saying "send" and the small print says the contact puts the rate in writing.
  3. D1–D3: give the dashboard a recognition H1, the funnel's rival noun, and a "You keep" tile that reads in order; and S6/S7, the two

disclaimers out of the fee labels.

after the first. We bill the order.» · «Industry survey averages, not any one company's rate card.» · the dated, numbered sources line · «nothing for the second item in the box» · the lock buttons that name what you get · the pallet guess that admits it is a guess · the footer that says who, where and since when.

with" · "keeps you" in the wizard reveal · "live" in the dashboard H1.

customer line, run the weird twenty against the bill screen's control (timing: what Q4 does to the other column; micro-human: the invoice you forward to your accountant with a question mark).

Applying is a separate step: the items are on the Launch Center as one APPROVE / DENY / FEEDBACK list (copychief-r1-items.json next to this file); approved rewrites ship in one deploy to both test screens at once, so the split test stays fair, then re-extract.