CellScience · What the competitors' ads say · headlines and primary texts
Read 2026-10-12 from the house Ad Library sweeps for astaxanthin (brand sweeps: AstaReal, Cellular Daily and Rovina, Cymbiotika, Double Wood, IM8, Life Extension, Mercola, Nutrex BioAstin, Ritual, Sports Research, Tru Niagen, Visiovance; keyword sweeps: astaxanthin, antioxidant, cellular health, kidney support, joints over 60, eye strain, collagen for women over 50; and the traffic sweeps behind the kept prelanders). 1,296 unique ads, 1,040 with a headline, 95 about kidneys. David's question: "What headlines do our competitors use? And share text?"
The short version
- They put the aggression in the primary text, not the headline. The headline is a soft benefit line or a call to action. The primary text is where the story, the fear and the enemy live, and in the kidney niche it runs 2,000 to 3,500 words.
- Three headline habits. A bland benefit line repeated across dozens of ads ("Natural Relief in Weeks", "Support stamina and heart health every day", "Feel Like Yourself Again"). The call to action as the headline ("👉 Click here and restore your vision tomorrow"). The fight-or-blame line ("Fight Back Against Macular Degeneration!", "Don't Blame Your Lifestyle — Fix The Macula Pigment First"). Astaxanthin brands add proof and offer lines ("Clinically Dosed Astaxanthin — No Fillers, Just Results", "1 Supplement, 9 Benefits", "BUY 1 GET 1 FREE!").
- The kidney story ad has one anatomy. A named narrator over 50. The lab numbers. "We'll keep an eye on it." The sacrifice that changed nothing. A death or a dialysis chair in the family. The discovery at 3 a.m. in a support group. The enemy (the doctor who waits, the industry that profits). Then "Learn more."
- Our round-two headlines are more aggressive than anything the kidney competitors run in the headline slot. That is a gap, not a mistake. What we do not yet have is their long story text. One per ad is the natural round three.
Headlines: the numbers
| Form | Share of 1,040 | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Plain statement or benefit | 76% | Natural Relief in Weeks · Support stamina and heart health every day · Feel Like Yourself Again |
| Warning or imperative | 7% | Don't Blame Your Lifestyle — Fix The Macula Pigment First · Stop wasting money on supplements that can't reach your cells |
| Doctor or authority | 5% | Eye Doctor rates supplements for AMD · Dermatologist-Backed Skin Protection |
| Offer | 4% | BUY 1 GET 1 FREE! · Half Price. Today Only. · Get 40% Off! |
| First person | 3% | I Lost Maple, my cat. I Won't Lose Another Cat |
| Number or proof | 3% | Clinically Dosed Astaxanthin — No Fillers, Just Results · 1 Supplement, 9 Benefits |
| Question | 1% | Who even gets filler anymore? |
Median length is 40 characters; half of them run longer than Meta shows in the feed. The most repeated lines across distinct ads:
| Headline | Ads |
|---|---|
| Fight Back Against Macular Degeneration! | 94 |
| Support stamina and heart health every day | 92 |
| 👉 Click here and restore your vision tomorrow | 54 |
| Natural Relief in Weeks | 39 |
| 🌿 Don't Blame Your Lifestyle — Fix The Macula Pigment First | 39 |
| Feel Like Yourself Again | 36 |
| 👉 Click here and stop Diabetic Retinopathy tomorrow | 29 |
| Clinically Dosed Astaxanthin — No Fillers, Just Results | 18 |
| Explore the Power of Astaxanthin Today! | 11 |
| Your Vision Is DYING — Here is the 7 Warning Signs | 10 |
The same headline sits on 30 to 90 different story bodies. The pages treat the headline as a constant and test the story.
Primary texts: the numbers
| What | Reading |
|---|---|
| Length | median 157 words; a quarter under 41 words (the brand ads), a quarter over 1,770 words (the story ads) |
| Opens with | a statement 54% · a first-person story 25% · a question 6% · an offer 6% · "If you…" 5% · a number 3% |
| Emoji | 32% of texts, almost all of them the brand ads, almost none of the stories |
| Closes with | "Read…" 41 · "Click…" 26 · "Tap…" 21 · "Try…" 20 · "See…" 14 · "Shop…" 10; the stories close on "Learn more" as the button and a soft line in the text |
The kidney cluster (95 ads)
| Days | Page | Headline | How the text opens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 140 | NaturaNoura | (none) | My dad was diagnosed with Stage 4 kidney disease three years ago. By the time they caught it, he was already on dialysis prep. |
| 109 | American Health Support Community | Natural Relief in Weeks | My eGFR was 42 and declining. Three years on every kidney supplement available. CoQ10. Turmeric. Herbal blends. All failed. |
| 109 | American Health Support Community | (none) | I need to tell you something that might piss you off about your nephrologist. My name is Robert. I'm 58 years old. |
| 103 | American Health Support Community | Natural Relief in Weeks | I Refused Dialysis Prep at Stage 3 Kidney Disease. My Nephrologist Said I Was Playing Russian Roulette. |
| 92 | Kendra Williams (Elavyn) | Why your kidney numbers get worse every 90 days even when you do everything right (it's not what your doctor told you) | My husband started dialysis in July, 2024. He did everything that doctor told him. Cut the salt. Drank more water. |
| 89 | Julie Anderson | (none) | My husband died on a dialysis chair earlier this year. He was fine at breakfast on a Tuesday morning. |
| 82 | Kendra Williams | Why your kidney numbers get worse every 90 days… | My mom started dialysis in July, 2013. She did everything that doctor told her. |
| 52 | Victoria Smith (Sculptique) | Relieve swelling — naturally | If your legs are swelling up, you're exhausted 24/7, and your doctor keeps brushing you off… |
Two anatomies, beat by beat:
Kendra Williams, 3,459 words, 92 days. The death first ("He died of kidney failure on October 19th at 5:44 AM. He was 63."). The bills. The grill still under its cover. The reason she is writing (the Facebook posts she used to make). The permission to keep scrolling ("I know it's long"). The checkup, the numbers, the "we'll keep an eye on it". The sacrifice list (no red meat, the scale, no Friday nights). The decline anyway. The discovery. The product as the thing she wishes someone had told her. "Learn more."
"Robert, 58", 2,072 words, 109 days. "I need to tell you something that might piss you off about your nephrologist." The three-year slide with the numbers. "Just keep doing what you're doing. We'll monitor it." Rage. The three things happening to you (your body screaming, the system gaslighting you toward dialysis, the industry that profits). The boiled-chicken life. The uncle's fistula. Crying at the kitchen table at midnight. The 3 a.m. support-group post from a woman whose numbers held. The product.
Both put real-looking lab values, a death and a named narrator into the ad. Our Truth Gate and the composite-narrator rule do not allow invented numbers or deaths; the structure is what travels, not the fabrication.
The astaxanthin brands (short copy)
| Page | Headline | Text style |
|---|---|---|
| Cellular Daily / Rovina (the pages behind the kept kidney prelanders) | 1 Supplement, 9 Benefits · Explore the Power of Astaxanthin Today! | 85 to 125 words: "Most antioxidants can't even reach where the damage is worst." Then the deep-ocean microalgae, 6,000× vitamin C, a benefit list, Buy 1 Get 1 Free, "Order now". Emoji. |
| Aurkina | BUY 1 GET 1 FREE! ❄️ | "Feeling tired, dull, or not quite like yourself?" then energy, cells, skin, the offer. 56 words. 251 days running. |
| Nutrex BioAstin, AstaReal, Sports Research | Clinically Dosed Astaxanthin — No Fillers, Just Results · brand and dose lines | Spec sheet copy: mg, source, studies, "shop now". |
| IM8, Cymbiotika, Tru Niagen | ingredient and founder lines | Wellness-brand voice, founder or celebrity, no story. |
What this means for our sets
- Keep the aggressive headlines. No kidney competitor runs "He told me to wait. I almost lost them" or "Don't blame the socks. Blame the filters" in the headline slot. Their headline is wallpaper. Ours can do work.
- Add one long story text per ad in round three. Meta takes five texts; swap one short text for a 300 to 600-word story that follows the anatomy above (the checkup, "we'll keep an eye on it", the sacrifice, the slide, the discovery) in our words and inside the gate: no invented lab values, no invented death, the organ and the enemy named. That is the one thing in their playbook we have not tested.
- Their proof line is our proof line. "6,000× vitamin C", "12 mg clinical dose", "deep-ocean microalgae" and "most antioxidants can't reach where the damage is worst" run on the Rovina ads that feed the pages ours were built from. Our texts already carry them.
- "If you…" openers are underused by everyone (5%). Our V5 text "If you got stage three and your eGFR is still dropping…" is one of the few in the niche.
- The pages test the story, not the headline. Ninety-plus bodies under one headline. Our five-and-five gives Meta the pairing; the per-headline breakdown will tell us in a week whether the headline earns its slot here.
Source corpus (not in git): the session scratchpad cs-ads/competitor-corpus.json, built from ads/research/astaxanthin/raw/.json and prelanders/kept-traffic-sweep.json. Five of David's ten swipe keeps are in it (Cellular Daily, Gary Brecka with Cymbiotika, American Health Support Community, Aurkina, NaturaNoura); the other five came from the video and TikTok sweeps, which carry no text.